Natalie was browsing eHarmony.com and noticed a cute guy. She decided to "Smile" at him to get his attention. Later that evening she received a response. They started to talk through the eHarmony messaging system. A few days later they went on their first date. Their first date lasted 6 hours and they haven't been able to escape each other since.

Logan took Natalie to the spot of their first date at the Shops at Legacy. They went to sit on the steps in front of a pond, where they had spent hours sitting and talking on their first date. After a while Logan worked up the courage to tell Natalie that he had a question to ask her. To which she responded "No, no, no you don't. Shut up. No you don't." After actually asking the question Natalie said "Yes!" to the surprise of everybody.